Dan Kennedy's Rock On
There is a moment described by author Dan Kennedy in his brilliant music biz memoir Rock On that reminds me of an almost-surreal experience from my own jaded past. Back in the early-90s, before the worldwide web had become this endless string of billboards and rest stops on the much-vaunted “Information Superhighway,” and only freaks and geeks knew of its existence, the Reverend was asked by a friend to sit in on an important Music Row meeting. The guys behind IUMA – the Internet Underground Music Archive, an earnest early attempt at bringing music online – had come to
The IUMA guy’s presentation was geared towards the person who was, at the time, the manager of the biggest country music star on the planet, although there were label folks and other industry types present. They attempted to explain the basic mechanics of the web 1.0, hyping the medium’s potential as a way for artists to take their music directly to the audience. Sadly, although the IUMA concept sparked this scribe’s imagination, it challenged the staid conservatism of Music Row’s old guard: the idea of the web as anything that that the country music industry needed to worry about was dismissed by some and endlessly ridiculed by others.
By the end of the ‘90s, the major record labels would see their dominance under assault by the new digital technology, as everything from the worldwide web and Napster to mp3 files and peer-to-peer networking would create cultural changes that would rock the industry from the top floors down to the foundation. In Rock On, Kennedy sadly describes the one great idea that he had during his brief but tumultuous tenure in the recording industry.
In a big corporate meeting, Kennedy pitched the idea of a “digital only” artist contract, essentially the launching of an online label for developing artists that would allow their music to be heard at a significantly lower cost to the label than a traditional record deal. If enough of a buzz grew around an artist, along with the demand for a physical product (i.e. CD), the label retained the right to release an album through the usual distribution chain and retailers.
It was a fine idea that Kennedy had, brilliant really, and one that has since been built upon with varying levels of success by folks like Magnatune, and even experimented with by major labels like Universal. In Kennedy’s story, however, his idea suffers the slings-and-arrows of bureaucratic turf wars as pea-brained corporate managers defend their departments against a perceived increase in workload, but are too self-involved and insecure to allow anyone else in the organization to pick up the idea and run with it.
It is to Kennedy’s credit that he can write about such a magnificent, flaming defeat with humor instead of crawling into a corner in the fetal position with a bottle of Johnny Walker Red. So it goes throughout Rock On, Kennedy’s hilarious and all-too-sadly-familiar memoir of his experience in the recording industry. Hired as a marketing manager – “Director of Creative Development,” actually – for Atlantic Records, lifelong music lover Kennedy thought that he’d landed his rock-n-roll dream job. Instead, what he found was an insulated society that had its own language and its own style of office politics in an odd corporate culture where the achievements of decades past often allowed one to skate through the present with a corner office and (high) six-figure salary.
In short, Rock On is a document of the waning fortunes of the recording industry in the 21st century, Kennedy witnessing firsthand the dying throes of the entertainment giant that was the Warner Music Group. Hired by Atlantic Records on the basis of a single television commercial that he had put together for Motown, Kennedy had virtually no background in the music biz and little actual office experience to draw upon as he attempted to maneuver the corridors of power and intrigue. Throughout the carnival ride that was his eighteen months at
Along the way, Kennedy sweats his first corporate assignment – an ad campaign to promote 25 years of Phil Collins’ love songs – and later projects, such as a head-scratching cross-promotion by singer Jewel with a razor company that featured a song about not selling out. Hmmm… The events surrounding a Fat Joe commercial video shoot are a hoot, and Kennedy’s story about his creation of a radio public service announcement with the Donnas is priceless. Kennedy attends an Iggy & the Stooges performance and experiences a spiritual epiphany, and he chaperones a visiting Chinese student around town with wit and patience.
Kennedy keeps his chin up and his spirits high throughout these pages, even as he hides in his office and tries to figure out what he should be doing to earn his pay. The author’s self-effacing humor is the structure on which the stories in Rock On are built, Kennedy a talented writer with a gift for phrasing and a penchant for whimsy. Flights of fancy such as “My Six-Point System For Saving The Record Industry” or “A Field Guide To A Few Of The Species I’ve Spotted Here In The Office” are funny, yes, but also insightful and pointedly direct.
Rock On is a quick read, and entertaining as hell for anybody that loves music and wants a glimpse behind the curtain at the wild and wacky world of the recording industry. After sharing Dan Kennedy’s memories, you’ll recognize why the industry is in as bad a shape as it is…still, the spectacle makes for a fine book. (Algonquin Books)
(Click on the book cover to buy Rock On from Amazon.com)
Labels: book reviews, Dan Kennedy


4 Comments:
Was Dan's idea a good idea? Yes. Was it an original idea? No. It is pure hubris for him to assume that he was the first person at the record label he worked at that wanted to create a digital only label. In fact, from what I was told by one of those former execs that he had that meeting with, they were already in the process of creating a such a digital only label. So in another case of crying over spilt milk, because other people were already doing it, he decided to skewer them instead of giving them credit. Typical. He's no better than any of the execs he rails on in his book.
First of all, let's establish that I wouldn't know Dan Kennedy if he walked through the door handed me a bundle of money...and although I know a few people named "anonymous," I don't know if I know this particular one or not. I have no dog in this hunt one way or another, OK?
So, was Kennedy's idea original? Probably not, but it's been said that there's nothing new under the sun. Hell, I had an idea myself for a digital label back in 2002 or '03 and wrote about it in a number of venues. But to accuse him of "pure hubris" for suggesting such an idea is a bit much, don't you think? I don't recall Kennedy claiming exclusivity of the idea, just that it was a good idea and he had it.
Also, to compare Kennedy to the record execs he worked for is mighty low...I might add that Dan was much kinder to said execs than I have been with those that I've known and written about through the years. When you have to have your secretary print out emails for you to read because you're too damn stupid to use a computer, you don't have the right to an opinion about technology, much less make decisions about its use.
The crux of this issue is whether or not Atlantic Records (and the label's parent, Warner Music) was "in the process of creating such a digital only label." Although I personally can't say for certain, my experience tells me probably not, in spite of what the unnamed exec might have told you. This comment sounds like typical industry spin to me....
What "other people were already doing it" at the time? Given the timeline that Kennedy places his tenure at Atlantic (2002-03 I'd guess), I don't know of any major label that had a digital-only label up and running...Universal announced its UMe Digital label in late-2004, and after a flurry of activity from artists like Owsley, Dan Reed and the Shazam, I've seen nothing more from that experiment.
Maybe I missed it, but I haven't ever seen a digital-only label from Warner Music and, considering the way that Bronfman flushes cash down the toilet, I don't expect the company to last much longer anyway. Considering the technophobic nature of most record execs, and the industry's entrenched bureaucracy, any digital label launched by a major label was probably doomed to fail.
BTW, anonymous, 'round these parts if we're going to criticize somebody, we do it straight up, without hiding behind anonymity. I've leveled a lot of criticism against the industry through the years, and I've always put my real name behind my words. Sometimes it comes back to bite me on the ass, but so it goes. Next time, stand up for your comments, especially if you're going to make 'em about another person....
you go rev! you rock!
can't wait for the read.
does anyone know who all the "anonymous" folks are in his book? I just finished reading it and it was quite good - but if you are going to tell the story, name the names. By the way, what happened to some of the main characters, Chocolate Chip, etc...
thanks
Post a Comment
<< Home
Post
to del.icio.us | 